Skyler Nesheim, CTO at Dwolla.
As digital payment technologies continue to advance, pay by bank and open banking are transforming the global financial landscape. These innovations are reshaping how businesses and consumers transact, offering enhanced security, efficiency and convenience. While several countries have embraced these technologies, the United States has been slower to adopt them.
For tech leaders evaluating payment infrastructure investments, understanding both the opportunities and implementation challenges is crucial for strategic decision making.
Global Adoption Patterns And U.S. Market Dynamics
Europe leads global open banking adoption following the 2018 implementation of PSD2, with the U.K. achieving the highest third-party registrations. Asia-Pacific countries, including Singapore, Malaysia, Hong Kong and India, have established comprehensive frameworks, with Singapore’s Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) and Hong Kong’s four-phase open API framework demonstrating regulatory commitment to innovation. The U.S. has been slower to embrace these technologies despite efforts from the Financial Data Exchange (FDX) and NACHA‘s Innovation Alliance.
From my experience leading payment infrastructure development, several factors contribute to slower U.S. adoption. For instance, the fragmented regulatory environment lacks the unified mandates seen in Europe’s PSD2. Additionally, the established dominance of card networks creates entrenched business models resistant to disruption.
Consumer behavior also differs significantly—while European consumers readily embrace bank-to-bank transfers, American consumers remain comfortable with existing payment methods, requiring more compelling value propositions to drive adoption.
Implementation Challenges Tech Leaders Must Navigate
Before pursuing open banking initiatives, tech leaders should understand the primary implementation challenges. Regulatory uncertainty tops the list, as the U.S. lacks comprehensive federal frameworks governing open banking, creating compliance complexity across state jurisdictions. Data security concerns represent another significant hurdle—both organizations and consumers worry about exposing sensitive financial information to third-party providers.
Technical integration challenges compound these issues. Legacy banking systems often lack modern API capabilities, requiring substantial infrastructure investments. Many financial institutions struggle with data standardization, making seamless integrations difficult. Additionally, consumer trust remains fragile, with privacy concerns and limited awareness of open banking benefits creating adoption barriers.
Organizations also face operational challenges including staff training requirements, new risk management protocols and the need for 24/7 monitoring capabilities that traditional banking operations haven’t required. These factors demand careful planning and substantial resource allocation.
Strategic Benefits And Use Cases
Despite implementation challenges, open banking can offer advantages when executed properly. The synergistic relationship between pay by bank, open banking and instant payments creates powerful opportunities. Open banking provides secure account access with user consent, enabling pay-by-bank transactions that bypass traditional card networks. When executed through instant payment rails like FedNow or RTP, funds move in real time, creating an efficient payment ecosystem.
Real estate, for instance, is one sector I’ve found presents particularly promising use cases, enabling mobile-based rent payments and property purchases without traditional banking visits. E-commerce applications for high-value items like event tickets and art sales can reduce fraud risk while improving customer experience. Whether paying bills, transferring funds to friends and family or making purchases online, these technologies allow users to initiate transactions wherever they are without disruption.
These implementations can offer measurable benefits: reduced transaction costs, enhanced security through direct bank transfers and improved cash flow through instant settlement.
Implementation Strategies For Tech Leaders
Based on my experience implementing payment infrastructure solutions, tech leaders should adopt a phased approach to open banking integration. Start with pilot programs targeting specific use cases with measurable outcomes. This allows teams to build expertise while demonstrating value to stakeholders.
A partnership strategy is also crucial for success. Rather than building everything in-house, collaborate with established payment providers who have navigated regulatory requirements and possess proven API infrastructures. This approach reduces implementation risk while accelerating time-to-market.
Be sure to invest in security architecture from day one, such as robust authentication protocols, real-time fraud monitoring and comprehensive audit trails. These foundational elements build consumer trust while ensuring regulatory compliance.
Focus on user experience design that emphasizes simplicity and transparency. Consumer adoption depends on intuitive interfaces that clearly communicate security measures and transaction flows. Consider conducting user research to understand specific concerns and preferences within your target market.
Finally, develop comprehensive change management programs for internal teams. Open banking requires new operational procedures, monitoring capabilities and customer support protocols. Training programs should cover technical implementation, regulatory requirements and customer communication strategies.
Leading Through Strategic Implementation
The next three to five years will likely see significant growth in pay-by-bank adoption as consumer awareness increases and regulatory frameworks evolve. I believe that tech leaders who begin strategic planning now will best be positioned to capitalize on this shift.
Success requires viewing open banking not as a standalone solution but as part of a comprehensive payment strategy. Organizations should evaluate how these technologies integrate with existing infrastructure while supporting future innovation requirements.
The most successful implementations will come from tech leaders who balance innovation with pragmatic risk management, building secure, scalable solutions that serve both business objectives and customer needs. By taking measured, strategic approaches to open banking adoption, technology organizations can position themselves at the forefront of payment innovation while maintaining the security and reliability enterprise customers demand.
Forbes Technology Council is an invitation-only community for world-class CIOs, CTOs and technology executives. Do I qualify?