Navigating the risks and rewards of hybrid finance

The financial landscape is undergoing a significant transformation as fintechs and traditional banks increasingly converge, forging a dynamic new ecosystem. This fusion, characterised by blurred lines and innovative hybrid models, presents both exciting opportunities and novel risks.

From neobanks expanding their offerings to fintechs acquiring bank charters, this evolving space promises enhanced customer experiences and new revenue streams. However, navigating this new and ever-evolving landscape poses considerable challenges for fintechs venturing into banking. Understanding these opportunities and, more importantly, the inherent risks is crucial for stakeholders in this burgeoning fintech-banking fusion.

Hybrid financial companies blend fintech agility with traditional banking stability. Neobanks, for instance, started out purely digital, but many now offer checking accounts, savings options, and loans. Examples include Chime and Revolut, both of which expanded into traditional banking territory. Fintechs acquiring bank charters — like SoFi — demonstrate another hybrid model, mixing innovation with regulatory credibility.

It’s worth noting that the motivations of fintechs and banks vary. Fintechs want customers and stable income, turning occasional app users into loyal banking clients. Banks, meanwhile, seek fresh ideas and new customers, particularly younger demographics drawn to digital convenience.

Hybrid finance provides customers with smoother, tailored experiences. Instead of separate banking and payment apps, imagine an app managing all financial needs — spending, saving, investing — in one spot. That simplicity boosts satisfaction.

Fintech companies gain significant advantages by tapping existing bank infrastructure. This gives them instant access to wide customer networks, speeding growth without massive investments in physical branches or compliance systems.

This fusion unlocks new ways to make money. Fintechs that offer loans, insurance, or investments alongside basic banking earn revenue from multiple streams. Customers get convenience, fintechs boost earnings — it’s a win-win scenario.

Finally, the agility fintech brings to traditional banking operations creates efficiency. Fintechs quickly test new ideas and streamline outdated processes, helping banks become leaner and faster. This pushes the financial industry forward, ensuring innovation becomes a standard part of banking’s future.

The high stakes for fintechs entering banking involve navigating a complex regulatory landscape, managing significant operational risks, addressing potential financial instability, and safeguarding against reputational damage. Let’s explore these risks in more detail.

Entering banking isn’t easy or cheap. Fintech companies must get licenses, either national, state-level, or specialised charters. Each requires extensive paperwork, heavy upfront investment, and months — even years — of waiting for approval. Mistakes at this stage can halt progress entirely.

Once licensed, compliance never stops. Fintech banks must constantly meet strict anti-money laundering (AML) rules and Know Your Customer (KYC) standards. Data privacy regulations, consumer protections, and capital adequacy requirements demand significant resources and ongoing oversight. If your compliance slips, heavy fines and penalties follow swiftly.

Regulations also evolve continuously. Fintech banks must adjust quickly to new rules or interpretations, adding complexity and costs. What was compliant yesterday may require changes tomorrow, creating a constant regulatory juggling act.

As fintech banks offer more services, their cybersecurity challenges multiply. Managing larger customer bases and more data dramatically expands the threat landscape, giving attackers more entry points.

Cyber threats targeting financial companies grow increasingly sophisticated. Defences that once worked might now fail against highly skilled hackers focused on fintech banking institutions. Strong, updated cybersecurity systems become crucial for preventing devastating breaches.

If breaches happen, the fallout can cripple your business. Data leaks carry massive financial penalties, legal costs, and customer lawsuits. Reputation damage often lasts years, pushing customers towards competitors and causing lasting financial harm.

Banking also demands rigorous financial discipline. Regulators require substantial capital reserves, ensuring banks have enough cash to handle unexpected downturns or losses. Liquidity management is another crucial aspect. Fintech banks must accurately forecast and manage cash flow daily, meeting customer withdrawal demands without fail.

Credit risk assessment becomes essential as fintech banks offer lending products. Evaluating creditworthiness is complex, requiring experienced teams and proven systems. Operational resilience — robust tech infrastructure, disaster recovery, and detailed business continuity plans — protects fintech banks from costly disruptions.

As fintechs increasingly navigate the complexities of hybrid finance, a robust and adaptable approach to risk management becomes paramount for ensuring stability, regulatory compliance, and sustained growth.

An excellent approach for fintech leaders is to build compliance directly into your products from day one. Known as “Compliance by Design,” this approach ensures regulatory concerns shape your business decisions early, reducing surprises later. It also saves significant time and money when adapting to shifting regulations.

Use Regulatory Technology (RegTech) to simplify your compliance tasks. RegTech automates checks, monitoring transactions for red flags and alerting your team immediately. This automation allows your staff to focus on strategy instead of tedious manual compliance duties.

Partner with regulatory and legal specialists. Experts help navigate the complicated banking rules efficiently, ensuring you avoid costly compliance errors. With their guidance, your business moves smoothly through licensing and ongoing regulatory demands.

Use multiple security layers to protect sensitive data. Advanced encryption, multi-factor authentication, and real-time intrusion detection systems keep hackers at bay. Multiple layers provide critical redundancy, giving you extra protection if one security measure fails.

Develop clear and strict data governance policies. Know precisely how customer data flows through your systems, ensuring compliance with strict privacy laws. It might seem straightforward, but it’s vital. Protecting customer data effectively boosts trust, strengthening your brand.

Create detailed incident response plans ahead of breaches. And clearly outline response roles, immediate actions, and crisis communications. Remember that preparation reduces confusion during attacks, minimising financial and reputational damage.

Carefully forecast capital needs to ensure adequate reserves. Strong capital planning protects your business from unexpected downturns or shocks. Embrace the old adage, “hope for the best, prepare for the worst.”

Furthermore, manage liquidity rigorously, tracking daily cash demands to reliably meet customer withdrawals and maintain trust. Evaluate credit risk thoroughly, assessing customer creditworthiness carefully. Finally, build scalable infrastructure, ensuring smooth operations during rapid growth or unexpected disruptions.

Insurance is essential for fintechs venturing into banking. Cyber liability coverage protects you from heavy losses due to data breaches or cyberattacks. Professional liability insurance shields you against costly claims from service errors or oversights. Directors and officers’ coverage defends company leaders against lawsuits and regulatory actions. And that’s just for starters.

Hybrid fintech-banking models face unique risks, so standard coverage won’t always fit. Tailored insurance policies, crafted specifically for your business, provide the specialised protection necessary to navigate these new challenges confidently and keep your company secure.

Jonathan Mitchell is Financial Practice Lead at Founder Shield

“Fintech meets banking: Navigating the risks and rewards of hybrid finance” was originally created and published by Retail Banker International, a GlobalData owned brand.

The information on this site has been included in good faith for general informational purposes only. It is not intended to amount to advice on which you should rely, and we give no representation, warranty or guarantee, whether express or implied as to its accuracy or completeness. You must obtain professional or specialist advice before taking, or refraining from, any action on the basis of the content on our site.