19 E. Main St., Brocton, which is now the location of Morse Funeral Home, was an ice cream parlor before.
A Buffalo hospital has officially purchased property where a new hospital is scheduled to be built in Fredonia.
The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from May 7-12.
During this time period, 412 Main Street, LLC sold 412 Main St., Fredonia to Kaleida Health of Buffalo for $733,000. The property is 30 acres of land.
412 Main St., LLC bought the parcel in 2023 for $720,000. That LLC is owned by Brooks Hospital. With this transaction Brooks Hospital has officially sold the property to Kaleida Health.
In 2024, Gov. Kathy Hochul announced an agreement with Kaleida Health and Brooks-TLC Health Systems to build a new hospital in Fredonia, with the state kicking in $74 million.
125 W. Main St., Sherman has been sold. It was previously the location of Irons Agency Insurance.
Photos by Gregory Bacon
The hospital plans are still being reviewed by Fredonia officials.
In a separate sale, Joseph Irons sold 125 W. Main St., Sherman to 125 W. Main St NY, LLC of Albany for $69,000. This was the location of Irons Agency Insurance, which is no longer operating at that location.
Also during this time, KBH Property, LLC of Brocton sold 19 E. Main St., Brocton to Daniel and Bette Distasio for $160,000. This was the location of an ice cream parlor called Sweet Creams and is now the location of Morse Funeral Home. The move was reported in the OBSERVER in late May and took effect June 1.
There was one sale that was seven figures. Bedford Property Consultants, LLC of Westfield sold 4882 Potter Road, Chautauqua town to Chautauqua Heights Manor, LLC of Jamestown for $1.1 million. Chautauqua Heights Manor is a large estate and historic Inn that offers luxury accommodations. On Facebook, Chautauqua Heights Manor posted that this spring it had sold off its cottage and 11 acres of the manor and that the cottage would be available as a vacation rental.
Including the sales previously mentioned, from May 7-12 there were six sales that were $250,000 or higher. The remaining top sales are as follows:
– 2714 Shadyside Road, Mina sold for $775,000.
– 4437 Chautauqua-Stedman Road, Chautauqua town sold for $439,000.
– 6322 Route 5, Portland sold for $352,000.
– 2567 Palm Road, Ellicott sold for $276,000.
Overall, from May 7-12 there were 74 transactions. The full list of sales higher than $1 is as follows:
MAY 7-9
Richard and Sally Zahm sold a parcel on Davison Road, Cherry Creek to Henry and Edna Hershberger for $199,900.
412 Main Street, LLC of Dunkirk sold 412 Main St., Fredonia to Kaleida Health of Buffalo for $733,000.
Bedford Property Consultants, LLC of Westfield sold 4882 Potter Road, Chautauqua town to Chautauqua Heights Manor, LLC of Jamestown for $1.1 million.
Joseph Irons sold 125 W. Main St., Sherman to 125 W. Main St NY, LLC of Albany for $69,000.
Paul Souter sold 6322 Route 5, Portland to 330 Holdings, LLC of Cheektowaga for $352,000.
Cheap Lands, Inc. of Port Saint Lucie, Fla. sold 441 Winsor St., Jamestown to Crystal Vaughn for $3,150.
Kathy Ferneza sold 1 Chestnut St., Forestville, town of Hanover, to TNT Houses to Homes, LLC of Silver Creek for $75,000.
Scott Imhoff sold 21 Seel St., Dunkirk to Richard and Laura Cain for $150,000.
Randall Scott sold 114 Vega St., Jamestown to Steven Rustrian for $88,000.
Zachery and Jennifer Seal sold 2714 Shadyside Road, Mina to Anthony and Kathleen Wiglusz for $775,000.
Benjamin Treadway sold 6031 Mill Road, Chautauqua town to James Kistner II and Tara Keller for $96,000.
James and Renee Pasquale sold a parcel on Webster Road, Pomfret to Luke Vosz for $75,000.
Ralph Campbell Jr., Jody Campbell and Mary Dibari sold 17 N. Gazelle St., Dunkirk to Alec Stanley for $100,000.
A referee for Rose Crampton sold 10356 Chestnut Road, Pomfret to Steven Glasier for $50,493.
Sherri Gerula sold 510 Rt. 394, Poland to Alden Brown for $134,500.
James Trotter sold 649 Sandberg Road, Carroll to Richard Windsor for $48,000.
Timothy Lutgen sold 6760 Bowers Road, Stockton to Edward Brisky for $30,000.
Ricky Ayers sold a 9 acre parcel on Prospect Street, Sherman to Antuk Development, LLC of Mayville for $53,500.
Matthew Weilacher sold 120 Buffalo St., Jamestown to Anthony Rodriguez for $85,000.
KBH Property, LLC of Brocton sold 19 E. Main St., Brocton to Daniel and Bette Distasio for $160,000.
Marie Derby sold 264 King St., Jamestown to Kimberly Dickerson for $104,900.
The Sharyn Soldano Asset Protection Trust sold 2567 Palm Road, Ellicott to Nathan Alm for $276,000.
The executrix of the Last Will and Testament of James Anson sold 614 Main St., Dunkirk to Homayoun Ghaderi for $55,000.
Bruce Piatz sold 808 N. Main St., Jamestown to Michael and Rachel Brown for $130,000.
The executrices of the Last Will and Testament of Sarah Lesch sold a vacant 27 acre parcel on Berry Road, Pomfret to Geoffrey Lesch-Wragge for $100,000.
Angelo Rivera sold 6703 S. Main St., Cherry Creek to Timothy Murphy for $16,000.
Lake Erie Hidden Treasures, LLC of Ripley sold 8504 East Forest Ave., Portland to KBH Property, LLC of Brocton for $150,000.
Dale and Rosalie Woods sold 23 Holt St., Westfield to Scott and Maria Bova for $185,000.
John and Ryanne Hickey sold 475 Front St., Jamestown to Wilmari Guzman and Ryan Cunningham for $193,000.
Brittany Dorris-Callis sold 622 Barrows St., Jamestown to Kevin and Amy Patterson for $62,000.
James Rizzo sold 3456 Rt. 5, Sheridan to Apostolos Spintzos and Valerie Catsadimas for $247,000.
David Leathers and Susan Smith sold 12 Snell Place, Jamestown to Patricia Josephson for $122,000.
Mark Rauenzahn sold 4437 Chautauqua-Stedman Road, Chautauqua town to Joelle Woodward for $439,000.
Alice Sanchez sold 815 Prendergast Ave., Jamestown to Esteban Santiago for $20,000.
MAY 12
BDS Sales & Marketing, Inc. of Grand Island sold 32 E. Second St., Westfield to Kingpenny, LLC of Elma for $115,500.
Carlos Brunet sold 412 Dove St., Dunkirk to Lashonda Moreland for $125,000.
Constantino Rentals, LLC of Frewsburg sold 270 Hallock St., Jamestown to Dusty Golem for $90,000.
PPP Future Development Inc. of Alexander, NY sold part of 3326 Sprague Hill Road, Poland to Ross Willis and Carolina Barba-Willis for $16,500.
Amos and Mary Byler sold 3427 Gerry Levant Road, Ellicott to Mose and Sally Byler for $75,000.
Michele Steward, Michael Stratton, Diane Miraglia and Judy Stratton sold 24 Bank St., Westfield to The Ronald G. Almeter and Barbara L. Fay Family Trust for $170,000. The family trust sold it to Kaitlynne Almeter and Collin Genthner for $92,000.
Heather Mendell sold 2111 Buffalo St. Ext., Ellicott to Kylea Andreano and Kyle Nazario for $186,170.
Jacquelyn Kopczynski sold 2800 Rt. 39, Sheridan to Hailey Halvorsen for $35,000.
Lisa Emke sold 5521 Rt. 62, Ellington to Zachary Caldwell for $5,000.
Jenny Sterner, Janet Deming VanCuren, June Abbey, and Judy Clark sold 8771 Hahn Road, Pomfret to Karen Meilleur for $68,000.
